GoHotelly
4-star hotel

SOUTH SHIRE a Little Hotel

Stay at SOUTH SHIRE a Little Hotel, a 4.7-rated inn in Bennington, VT offering opulent rooms with fireplaces, LGBTQ+ friendly amenities, near Bennington Museum & Main Street.

124 Elm St, Bennington, VT 05201, United States View on map
9.4/10
Exceptional Based on 100 recent guest reviews
What recent guests emphasize

Comfortable historic charm with attentive service

Guests appreciate the inn's cozy, opulently decorated rooms featuring fireplaces and unique vintage touches. The friendly staff and convenient location near downtown Bennington enhance the overall stay. Some note minor issues with heating and breakfast quality, providing a balanced perspective for future visitors.

Guests often praise

  • Charming, beautifully decorated rooms with historic details and comfortable beds
  • Warm fireplaces in many rooms, enhancing the cozy atmosphere
  • Friendly, accommodating staff providing attentive service and helpful communication
  • Convenient location within walking distance to shops, restaurants, and local attractions
  • Enjoyable communal spaces such as the parlor with fireplace, piano, and beverage bar

Worth knowing

  • Some rooms require climbing steep stairs, which may be challenging for some guests
  • Heating systems vary; a few guests experienced initial issues but alternatives were provided
  • Breakfast receives mixed feedback regarding variety and freshness; some guests chose to dine out
  • The inn has a distinctly historic and quirky vibe, which may not suit those seeking modern minimalism
  • Parking and late check-in arrangements require prior communication for smooth access

Best for

  • Travelers seeking a quaint, historic Victorian inn with character
  • Visitors who appreciate cozy fireplaces and vintage decor in their accommodations
  • LGBTQ+ friendly guests looking for an inclusive atmosphere
  • Couples and small groups wanting a quiet, charming base near downtown Bennington
  • Guests interested in exploring local museums, art institutes, and outdoor activities nearby
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to SOUTH SHIRE a Little Hotel

SOUTH SHIRE a Little Hotel is a charming inn situated in a stately Victorian building dating back to 1887, located on Elm Street in Bennington, Vermont. The property stands about 0.8 miles from the Bennington Museum and is within easy walking distance of the shops and restaurants on Main Street, making it well placed for guests looking to explore the local area on foot.

The inn offers rooms decorated with period details including canopy and poster beds, fireplaces, and soaking tubs, providing a distinctive historic atmosphere. Reviewers often highlight the comfortable beds and the warmth provided by fireplaces or radiators, which helps create a cozy environment even during cold weather. Some rooms feature charming touches such as vintage telephones and typewriters, enhancing the unique character of the stay.

Facilities include communal areas where guests can relax by the fire or enjoy tea and coffee, with additional on-site dining options praised for quality and service. The property is known to be LGBTQ+ friendly, welcoming a diverse range of visitors. While some feedback notes varying opinions on breakfast offerings, the overall hospitality and ambiance receive positive mentions from many past guests.

For those interested in cultural and outdoor activities, nearby attractions such as the Bennington Battle Monument, the Bennington Museum, and the Clark Art Institute offer sightseeing opportunities. Albany International Airport and Rutland Southern Vermont Regional Airport are within an hour's drive, providing accessible options for travelers.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

TM
Troy MacNeill Mar 28, 2026
10

A+ service, room we stayed in was perfect size with king bed. had an issue with heater first night but Inn Keeper was great to deal with and provided alternative heat source on first evening plus they have working fireplace (bonus++). We stayed 3 nights and just enjoyed ourselves during our visit. would definitely stay here again.

CM
Christina Madden Mar 16, 2026
10

A delightful place to stay. We met up with two other couples, and we all loved the place. They went out of their way to accommodate us for dinner, setting us up in the parlor where could talk without disturbing other diners. Thai food was delicious. Our room had some nice touches such as an old telephone and typewriter. Heat was from a radiator and it kept us toasty warm. The mattress was very comfortable. We enjoyed having drinks in the parlor. Breakfast was delicious. We would definitely stay there again.

PB
Paz Baum Feb 24, 2026
10

The South Shire Inn was absolutely perfect! The Otto Suite was beautiful and comfortable. The fireplace comes with duraflame logs and a lighter, making it super easy to use. Breakfast the next day was lovely as well. The Inn is within walking distance to the shops downtown. Highly recommend staying here!

EH
Erin Hobson Feb 22, 2026
10

Adorable and quirky place and a great value. We booked here to XC ski at Prospect Mountain. The weather didn’t cooperate, but we still had fun hanging out in Bennington and Manchester. We booked the Peach Room, which had a cozy bed and an enormous bathroom. The temperature went down to single digits one night and I was snug and warm. The Thai restaurant Taan has incredible food. We had dinner one night and it was the best Thai food I’ve ever had. There’s a communal area between the restaurant and lobby with a fireplace, piano, and tea and coffee bar. It was nice to sit by the fire with a cup of tea. The owner was really nice and fun to chat with.

BS
Bethany Shanley Feb 08, 2026
8.0

My husband and I popped up to Bennington for a quick weekend away. This was our first time staying at South Shire. We knew we'd be arriving after the allotted check in time, but as per their instructions, let them know in advance that we'd be a little late, gave them an ETA, and let them know once we were on our way. There was a employee there to greet us with our key when we arrived, which made check in seamless. We booked the Wentworth room. Our room was directly off of the lobby, so we did hear the guests walking up and down the stairs and a little bit of kitchen noise in the morning, but it was nothing that caused issue at all. The room was nicely appointed with complimentary robes for use, lovely bar soap (Beekman 1802) and nice towels. We had fantastic water pressure (almost felt like a massage from the shower head) with no decline in the hot water. The bed was a higher bed with lovely soft sheets and a comfortable down comforter. The bed (mattress) itself wasn't super comfortable, and caused a bit of sleeplessness. The fireplace was stocked with a dura-flame log with instructions for use and added a lovely ambiance to our room. Wifi instructions were clearly marked, and a list of suggested local restaurants, as well as their own restaurant's menu, were displayed on the desk. There was no TV, but after a day of walking around we found we didn't miss it and just enjoyed each others company and conversation instead. We didn't eat at South Shire, opting instead to walk to a few local restaurants we know and love, but got a night cap (wine and beer) after getting back, served by the restaurant. We enjoyed sitting on the couch in the lounge by the fire. Overall, we felt the price was great, the location unbeatable, and service sufficient for what we wanted for the weekend. We'd love to see an updated mattress, but other than that, wouldn't change a thing! We'd overall give it a 4.5 out of 5, but it won't let that be an option on the rating system. Thank you for a lovely weekend away.

PM
Patricia Murphy Feb 04, 2026
8.0

Just left, my thoughts? The home itself was quite beautiful. Our room, the Gold Room, was at the top of very steep stairs. The room was beautiful and huge. The bed was quite comfortable and the fireplace an extra added little romantic atmosphere. I could imagine what it was like actually living there "back in the day". The home itself was beautifully decorated. Loved the beamed ceilings. My few compliments was, it was very cold Although the owner provided a space heater. And that room didn't have an on suite bathroom. Some rooms did but not all. The bathroom assigned to your room, is however, a private one. Oh and no tv nor refrigerator, which would have been nice. We did not try the restaurant. But it has a good rating. Overall, a very quiet weekend, during the daytime hours. If your looking for quiet and relaxing place, this is a great choice.

KV
Karly Vaughn Jan 04, 2026
10

Such a cute little place to stay! Our room was clean and had a historic feel which we loved. The location was perfect to be able to walk into downtown Bennington. I wouldn't recommend the $10 breakfast since it was comprised of fruit with yogurt, stale bagels, and drinks (although the orange juice was really good). The staff was helpful and friendly, and overall, we really enjoyed our stay!

TM
Tiffany Massengale Jan 02, 2026
10

We truly enjoyed our visit. Everyone we dealt with was welcoming and accommodating. The house is so beautiful with unique finishings and details. We ate at the restaurant and it’s one of the best meals we have had. Delicious food with amazing service. Staying here was the epitome of delightful.

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find SOUTH SHIRE a Little Hotel

Bennington, Vermont, USA

This stately Victorian B&B dates from 1887 and is 0.8 miles from Bennington Museum, and 2 blocks from the shops and restaurants of Main Street.

  • Bus Terminal at 215 Pleasant St. 12 min Walk
  • Martins (Washington/Main) 5 min Walk
  • Brookside Apartments 5 min Walk
  • Albany International Airport 53 min Car · 1 hr 55 Transit
  • Rutland Southern Vermont Regional Airport 59 min Car · 1 hr 45 Transit
Things to do nearby

Worth the walk or a quick ride

Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Vermont. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.

Clark Art Institute 620 reviews

Clark Art Institute

225 South St, Williamstown, MA 01267, United States

4.9 · Art Museum
Bennington Battle Monument 1,999 reviews

Bennington Battle Monument

15 Monument Cir, Bennington, VT 05201, United States

4.6 · Monument
Bennington Museum 513 reviews

Bennington Museum

75 Main St, Bennington, VT 05201, United States

4.7 · Museum
People also viewed

Similar Inns in Vermont

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

2420 N 1st St, Carrizo Springs, TX 78834, United States

Energy Lodge Carrizo Springs

Energy Lodge Carrizo Springs offers comfortable extended stay lodging with a 3.8 rating, located at 2420 N 1st St, ideal for visit...

3.8 (29) View
4501 W 12th St, Sioux Falls, SD 57106, United States

West Twelve Properties

Stay at West Twelve Properties, a 3.6rated extended stay hotel in Sioux Falls, SD. Convenient location at 4501 W 12th St with rel...

3.6 (32) View
3701 N Country Dr, Traverse City, MI 49684, United States

Spark by Hilton Traverse City

Enjoy free WiFi, breakfast, and parking at Spark by Hilton Traverse City. Near Dennos Museum Center and local wineries in Michiga...

3.8 (59) View
1030 Canton Rd NW, Carrollton, OH 44615, United States

Microtel Inn & Suites by Wyndham Carrollton

Warm rooms and suites with free WiFi, breakfast, and parking. Fitness center, petfriendly, near Carroll Community Park and local...

4.2 (339) View
40 Arsenal Rd, York, PA 17404, United States

Ramada by Wyndham York Harrisburg Hershey

Stay at Ramada by Wyndham York Harrisburg Hershey, a 3.3star LGBTQ+ friendly hotel near York County History Center and Hollywood ...

3.3 (81) View
27355 Cabaret Dr, Novi, MI 48377, United States

Hilton Garden Inn Detroit/Novi

Stay at Hilton Garden Inn Detroit/Novi, a modern hotel near Fountain Walk offering indoor pool, fitness center, free WiFi, and ea...

4.3 (1,003) View
Share your stay

Stayed at SOUTH SHIRE a Little Hotel? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.